A few interesting things in the print and electronic media lately. This is a long post with a number of sub-entries, so keep scrolling!
First of all, this opinion piece—Little Australians need more then Harry Potter—in the Sydney Morning Herald escaped my attention for a couple of days. It's by Rosemary Johnston from the education faculty at UTS.
I'm not really sure what I think of the piece. First of all, there's certainly nothing wrong with it, and I don't quibble with anything Johnston has to say, and I agree wholeheartedly with the observation Though contemporary Australian children's literature is highly respected, I am not sure that Australians value its rich provenance, or the diverse ways it has contributed to ideas of nation and national identity. Johnston writes with clarity authority and the article is well informed, as you would expect from someone with Johnston's credentials.
It just kind of seems apropos of not very much to me. In canvassing a history of Australian children's lit and its place in "contributing to ideas of nation and national identity", the article reads to me a bit as if it could have been published twenty years ago, when contemporary Australian children's writers were finding new voices and contexts free of "stereotypes of Australianness", as a way of looking back and looking forward. But now it's just looking back. Johnston certainly isn't waxing nostalgic—she is firm about the quality and international standing of contemporary Australian children's literature, but she doesn't much go into specifics (and then she only cites books from the 70s and 80s).
I'm aware that Johnston is writing for a non-specialist audience, but I would hazard a guess that the average Herald reader doesn't need to be reminded of the glory days of the nascent Australian kids' books industry—and the comments posted on the related blog seem to bear this out. I'm thinking about Johnston's closing remarks: without a sense of the past, both good and not so good, we are oddly bereft. Are we—by which I mean the general community—really without a sense of the past as far as our literature for young readers is concerned?
This is what I mean by "apropos of nothing". The piece doesn't read like Johnston has an axe to grind. On the contrary, it's almost dispassionate. It's certainly not, as far as I am aware, a response to a current climate of thinking, or a particular "issue" that has popped up in schools or the media (of the "what's this rubbish they're publishing for our kids" ilk, which fortunately I haven't come across in any significant forum since, maybe when John Marsden published Dear Miffy). (And be warned, John's website is annoyingly slow to load and navigate.)
So, I am not complaining. I have entertained the idea that the article was commissioned in response to our* rather loud complaining on the SMH's Undercover blog and here on Misrule recently about the SMH's lack of coverage of the CBCA awards. If so, good. Great! in fact. I just wish it had had a bit more meat, a few more of challenging ideas about contemporary writing and publishing for young readers. I think you could do that for the general readers of the opinions page.
Perhaps now we can hope that Spectrum—the weekend arts section of the Herald—might make space for some broader-ranging and, dare I say without in any way meaning to insult Rosemary Johnston, contemporarily relevant discourse about the wide world of books for children and young adults. Spectrum has, as I have said before, improved its coverage of children's lit in its review pages enormously over the past couple of years, most recently with Angie Schiavone's review of three YA books (alas, not online that I can find).
If this were to happen, what kind of topics would people like to see covered? Post your thoughts here—you never know who is reading!
*I say "our" because I might have kicked it off with my perhaps
somewhat intemperate initial post on the Undercover blog, but it took
off like a storm here and on the SMH. My readers are a bolshie lot!
Back on the Undercover blog, the Australian new magazine for children under eight years, Little Ears, gets a nod. I haven't seen Little Ears yet, but it's edited by the redoubtable Di Bates, so it will be well worth checking out.
Subscribers to Di's Buzz Words online magazine will soon read an interview with—Me! I over-ran Di's word length by about 5000 words—she's edited it down to two and a half, and once the newsletter is out there, she's given me permission to publish the full catastrophe here, so keep posted (if you can bear the self-indulgence).
(Hey, Di—where's the link to Misrule on your website?!)
If you haven't already heard, Madeleine L'Engle died last week at the age of 88. There's been no shortage of media coverage of this most significant passing: check out obits and articles here, here and here. The blogosphere has also been busy: check out this, this and this. You can google the rest yourself.
Vale.
I subscribe to the US Publisher's Weekly free daily newsletter (and it's weekly children's book newsletter) and I recommend you do to. Apart from seeing what's going on in US publishing, PW hosts some fantastically interesting and entertaining blogs.
A couple that caught my eye this week:
This post, which will have just about every illustrator I know pea-green (if not carmine) with envy. Or maybe it's just me who wishes she had a delightful old country home with a two-story studio in the backyard. Anyway, Melissa Sweet is a gifted illustrator, and good luck to her!
I loved this one about publisher's rejection letters, linking to a NYTimes article.
Finally, this post links to an article about the state of book reviewing in US newspapers that I think Misrule readers will find pertinent and informative. I confess I haven't finished the full article—it's very long—so I might try and post again once I've absorbed the whole thing.
That's quite enough for one night. Off now to concentrate on the DVD of The Thief Lord, which has been on in the background as I have been blogging. (Vanessa Redgrave as a nun? Cool! Or—tee hee! And good to see Alexei Sayle is as nutty as ever...)
Oh, and I know I need to update my sidebar of "recent....". Will do soon.
Cheers.
Comments
Tue, 22.01.2013 19:21
Thanks for the book list! I th ink fiction books are one of t he best ways to understand cul ture. It helps us to und [...]
Tue, 18.09.2012 07:28
I swapped from Blogger to Word press and the Wordpress platfo rm picked up all my previous b logs and converted them. [...]
Fri, 31.08.2012 23:56
Hi Anna, I can get a messag e to Gaye on your behalf. C heers, Judith
Thu, 30.08.2012 12:03
Hi, i found this blog and was wondering is there any possibi lity to contact Gaye direct??? If there is one, please [...]
Tue, 20.03.2012 23:06
Unfortunately, Geraldine, I do n't do very much reviewing on the blog these days. However, if you send me the publi [...]
Sun, 18.03.2012 18:35
So, I came across this article whilst browsing Google. Anywa y, I attend this school and it is truly fantastic to s [...]
Sat, 17.03.2012 14:17
Thanks for this Judith ... gre at stuff. Would it be possibl e somehow for you to look at m y picture book:- "My Fea [...]
Fri, 10.02.2012 16:03
Dog in, Cat out is ridiculous. .try reading it at storytime l ol I'd prefer Animalia (Gra eme Base)and Looking for [...]
Thu, 15.12.2011 13:37
Hi, Judith, I;'m late in re ading this -- but I'm going to cut out the Steve Jobs quote from a prinout of your d [...]
Sat, 03.12.2011 09:43
What a terrific story. These s tate schools are doing terrifi c things. Through the dedicati on of the teachers and t [...]
Fri, 02.12.2011 21:01
"In the land of the talking tr ees" by Michael Noonan -a gorg eous fantasy about a soldier i n WW2 lost in PNG and sa [...]
Wed, 16.11.2011 08:18
Hey Judith I really enjoyed y our Apple journey. Our school had Apples, too. My wife, a de signer, banned me from P [...]
Sun, 13.11.2011 12:43
A very late comment, since I f ound your comments reproduced in the Sep. Bookseller and Pub lisher, Judith. I've bee [...]
Wed, 12.10.2011 04:50
I am a masters student of chil dren's literature at Makerere University in Uganda, East Afr ica. I must say the comm [...]
Sun, 02.10.2011 23:22
this sounds great--on my list it goes!