| Since it publication in October of last year (1992), Melina
Marchetta's debut Looking for Alibrandi has provoked widespread
praise and affection remarkable for a young adult novel; the all-to-familiar
story for authors and publishers of children's books is the long term
struggle for recognition from the mainstream "literati". Reviews
for Alibrandi, however, have been almost without exception excellent;
the reaction of author and Sydney
Morning Herald columnist Margaret McClusky, for instance, who said
"A must for all teenagers... Buy it for your H.S.C .- swamped offspring
before it is too late." (SMH. 14.11.92) being quite typical. The
attention has been both exciting and overwhelming for Marchetta, who has
nevertheless kept a clear vision of both her current success, and her
on-going career as a writer.
A notable feature of Marchetta's writing is the controlled, understated
tone of her protagonist Josephine's narrative. Integral to this tone is
humour, frequently self-deprecating and even defensive on Josephine's
part, and always sharp, observant and revealing. It is interesting to
discover, considering its intrinsic value to both the narrative and the
character of Josephine, that Marchetta did not consider the book to be
particularly funny, until readers began laughing aloud at passages such
as this;
Religion class, first period Monday morning, is the place to try to
pull the wool over the eyes of Sister Gregory. (She kept her male saint's
name although the custom went out years ago. She probably thinks it
will get her into heaven. I don't think she realises that feminism has
hit religion and that the female saints in heaven are probably also
in revolt.
Indeed, the opening of the novel is predicated on a joke, with Josephine
managing to talk her way out of trouble in the first lesson of her last
year at school. It serves as an excellent introduction to the character
of Josephine, who is intelligent and dramatic, funny and observant as
well as being quite self-absorbed. Similarly, this opening passage lets
the reader into some other of Marchetta's interests in telling the tale
of Josephine's coming of age; religion, sexuality, feminism, and the importance
of female friendship and guidance to this maturing young woman. Well into
the chapter, after the reader has begun to develop an understanding of
who Josephine is, she begins to address her experiences as an Italian-Australian;
...primary school was the only time I was people I could compare notes
with and find a comfortable place alongside. We'd slip our Italian and
Greek into our English and swap salami and prosciutto sandwiches at
lunch-time and life was good in the school-yard. Life outside school,
though, was a different story.
Much of the discussion of Alibrandi has centered around this
portrayal of a multi-cultural Australia, although remarkably, the novel
has managed to largely avoid the negative and superficial "issues"
pigeon-holing so much realist fiction for young adults is victim to. There
is no question that Marchetta's own experiences as an Italian-Australian
have informed her story. Nor is there any doubt that in Josephine Alibrandi
she has created a fresh non-Anglo-Australian voice of great power and
integrity. Nevertheless, Marchetta does find that the focus on the Italian
heritage of her protagonist (and herself) can be both distracting and
limiting; it was not, she says, her first impulse in telling Josephine
Alibrandi's story;
I was fascinated by my Nonna's experience of leaving her family when she
emigrated to Australia 60 years ago. I am very close to my own sisters,
and I couldn't imagine having to leave them forever. So I wanted to explore
that experience; what must it have been like for women like my Nonna to
never see their families again? Out of that came the relationships between
the women from three different generations. I think that is the most important
part of the book, and it's those relationships that I wanted to write
about. I certainly never intended to sit down and write a book about racism,
or about suicide or about any of the other "issues" that might
have ended up in it, and I really hate the thought that it would be used
as bibliotherapy; "here's this book that will solve all your problems
with racism" or whatever.
Another legacy of the shared Italian-Australian heritage of both author
and protagonist is the common assumption that the book must be autobiographical.
I suggested to Melina that this reading of her novel is in some ways complimentary,
being as it is an indication of the kind of response readers have to Josephine,
and to the lively and truthful tone of the novel; Marchetta has captured
her characters, their situation and the inner city suburbs of Sydney acutely
and precisely.
One letter I got was from a girl who'd read the book, and she was driving
through Glebe, and she said she kept expecting to see Josephine walking
along the street. It was great to think that someone had felt this way
about Josephine, that she could be real, but it's definitely not my autobiography.
Of course my experiences as an Italian-Australian are there, and I've
used things like my Nonna emigrating, but people ask me things like "Who's
John? Is he really a politician's son?" I didn't base the characters
on anyone, although I can see parts of myself in Josephine, and friends
have recognised things about themself that I didn't consciously put in.
But I would really hate it if people thought it was my family depicted,
and in some cases it would be very hurtful to my family if people thought
so. It would be terrible if people thought, for instance, that Christina's
father was my mother's father. My mother adores her father, and while
he was a stern man, like Christina's father, he adored his children and
his wife. And the relationship between Marcus and Josephine's Nonna is
completely fictitious, although I did have grandparents who lived in the
far north of Queensland.
A key interest of the novel, of course, is Josephine's development towards
a mature understanding of herself, and thus the ability to make informed
choices about her life and relationships. Indeed, Marchetta's working
(and preferred) title was The Emancipation of Alibrandi. A pivotal experience
in Josephine's story is the suicide of her close friend John Barton; his
death provides her with a tragic perspective for her own life and problems;
... The day John died was a nose-dive day and I hit the ground so hard
that I feel as if every part of me hurts. I remembered when we spoke
about our emancipation. The horror is that he had to die to achieve
his. The beauty is that I'm living to achieve mine.
I asked Melina if she had consciously worked towards John's death both
as an emotional meeting-point for much of the novel's concerns, and as
a catalyst for Josephine's emancipation;
Not at all. I actually spent a lot of time resisting killing John at all.
I knew from the start that he would have to commit suicide, but I really
didn't want to do it. If I'd had more time with him, he could have worked
things through, but given that the story was just one year in Josephine's
life, it wouldn't have been honest to rush him on to a happy ending; it
would have been ridiculous if he suddenly turned up at the end of the
book saying, "hey, I've told Dad I don't want to be a solicitor and
everything's OK." His death was the only way I could finish his story
given those constraints, and I guess it just became a natural point for
things to come together, in terms of the structure and so on.
Marchetta did not have a particular audience in mind when she set out
to explore these relationships, and in developing her central themes and
characters. She credits her editor at Penguin, Erica Irving, with giving
her the time (Penguin worked on the manuscript with Melina for three years
before publication) and encouragement to focus what was an unruly manuscript
on an audience, and to develop a cohesive and controlled story-line. This
inevitably led to some significant changes from the book's early drafts;
Christina and Michael were much more important in the early drafts. I
was really interested in their relationship, and I particularly like Christina;
I would have liked to have dome more with her. But the book was much too
long, and I needed to concentrate more on Josephine, so I had to push
them into the background a bit, which I'm sorry about. I also had another
girl in Josephine's group of friends, in fact, she was Josephine's best
friend, so I was a bit surprised when I realised she was the one that
had to go. But again, it really was too long and messy, and by cutting
out this best friend, who it turned out Josephine didn't need anyway in
terms of the plot, I could bring Lee into it much more. She'd been in
the background a bit, but I always really liked her, and I still think
she's one of the most interesting characters in the book, so that worked
out well.
Nevertheless, it is Josephine Alibrandi who is the novel's driving force,
and who is, perhaps, largely responsible for the warm reception the book
has received. It is fascinating, then, to discover that Marchetta herself
finds a lot about Josephine that she dislikes, and is surprised that readers
have been so overwhelmingly positive in their responses to her;
She's a bitch! She's so selfish, and she can't begin to see that other
people's problems are worse than her own. I kept telling a friend of mine
this, and she couldn't see what I was getting at until she'd read the
book three or four times, and then she said to me, "I see what you
mean about Josephine!"
The ambivalence Marchetta feels towards Josephine is revealed through
the characters of Sister Louise, her headmistress, and her boyfriend Jacob,
neither of whom hesitate to point out to Josephine when she is being selfish,
over-dramatic, or plain stupid. A quite shocking example of this is in
the scene where Jacob rescues Josephine from a violent mob of teenage
boys in a McDonalds carpark, and then abuses her for her stupidity in
spitting on and further antagonising the ring-leader. It is an indication
of the exasperation that Josephine provokes in those who care about her,
and Marchetta agrees with Jacob that Josephine's dramatic and impulsive
behaviour too frequently land her in avoidable unpleasantness. To be fair,
Josephine can be fairly hard on herself, and her ability at and willingness
for self-scrutiny develops as she matures. It is testament to Marchetta's
care in balancing the complexities of Josephine's character that the reader
can witness her tantrums and drama-queen turns, her often thoughtless
and selfish actions, and yet know that this is an essential part of her
emancipation, and that it does not detract from her vitality, compassion
and intelligence.
That Marchetta has achieved such a smooth and involving synthesis of character,
contemporary experience, humour, complex relationships and genuine emotion
in what is not merely her first novel, but her first published work of
any kind, is indication of a remarkable talent that will be fascinating
to watch develop.
Marchetta is working on a second novel, but stresses that she is not
going to rush the writing of it in order to quickly follow up Alibrandi's
success; "I'm a careful person, and I am quite happy to spend a couple
of years on this novel to make sure I get it right. " Undoubtedly,
expectations will be high, and Marchetta is determined not to be limited
by this, or by the perception that she is a particular type of novelist;
The novel I'm working on at the moment is really different to Alibrandi.
It's a mystery, and it's set in a country boarding school, I've had to
do a lot more research, and it won't be "multi-cultural" at
all.
I asked Melina about her approach to writing, and how she is currently
fitting in the writing of her second novel with her university studies.
Does she write regularly, and does she write to a plan? She began her
answer with a wry smile.
I heard Gary Crew speak at the (Sydney) Children's Book Fair a couple
of years ago, and he showed us his writing journal; it was fantastic,
all laid out with diagrams and so on. I rushed straight out and bought
one, but I never used it! No, I don't have a plan, I just write to begin
with, and then I find that about ten chapters in I have finally got my
characters; then I have to go back and re-write the early chapters, because
I find that the characters are really flat and undeveloped in them. This
is about where I'm up to in the second novel. And I do find it really
hard to write while I'm studying; I keep telling myself, "next holidays!"
*********************************

"Looking for Alibrandi" was made into a successful
feature film in 2000. The screenplay was written by Marchetta, and
she won the 2000 NSW
Premier's Literary Award for scriptwriting for her screenplay. The
ISBN of the film tie-in edition is 0140293507

"Looking for Alibrandi" was published in the US by Orchard
Books in 1999. ISBN: 0531301427 Unusually, the US publisher more or less
kept the Australian cover for their US edition. Unfortunately, the book
appears to be OP in the UK. |